Feedback Conversation Framework

A Practical Tool for Operational Leaders

This framework provides a structured approach to planning, delivering, and following up on feedback conversations in manufacturing and warehouse environments. Use it to prepare for both routine and challenging feedback situations.

PREPARATION PHASE

Context Analysis

• Performance Data: What specific metrics or observations will you reference?

  • Example: Quality metrics, production rates, safety observations

• Timing Considerations: When is the optimal time for this conversation?

  • Consider: Shift timing, workload, employee energy level

• Location Planning: Where will the conversation take place?

  • Consider: Privacy needs, noise level, comfort

• Expected Duration: How much time will you allocate?

  • Typically: 5-15 minutes for routine feedback, 15-30 for more significant issues

Self-Check Questions

• What is my emotional state regarding this situation?

• Am I clear on the specific behavior or outcome I want to address?

• What assumptions might I be making that I should verify?

• What is my goal for this conversation?

CONVERSATION STRUCTURE

Opening (Setting the Stage)

• Connection: Brief personal check-in

  • Example: "How has your shift been going so far?"

• Purpose: Clear statement of conversation purpose

  • Example: "I'd like to talk about what I observed during yesterday's changeover."

• Tone Setting: Statement that establishes constructive intent

  • Example: "My goal is to help ensure we're all working safely and efficiently."

Listening Phase (Start with Questions)

• Perspective Questions: (Select 2-3 appropriate to the situation)

  • "Can you walk me through how you're approaching this process?"

  • "What challenges are you experiencing with this task/procedure?"

  • "From your perspective, what factors are affecting your performance in this area?"

  • "What do you think is working well, and what could be improved?"

  • "What resources or support would help you in this situation?"

  • "How do you feel about your progress with this skill/task?"

• Active Listening Checklist:

  • Give full attention (no phone, radio, or distractions)

  • Take notes if appropriate

  • Ask follow-up questions for clarity

  • Summarize what you heard before moving on

Evidence Phase (Provide Specific Observations)

• Behavior Description: Specific, observable behavior without judgment

  • Template: "I noticed [specific observation] at [time/date/situation]."

• Impact Statement: Clear description of the effect

  • Template: "This resulted in [specific outcome/consequence]."

• Standard Reference: Connection to expectations

  • Template: "Our standard/expectation is [specific benchmark]."

Action Phase (Develop Improvement Steps)

• Collaborative Planning: Questions to engage the employee

  • Examples:

  • "What do you think would help improve this situation?"

  • "How could we approach this differently next time?"

  • "What specific steps would make the biggest difference?"

• Clear Agreement: Specific improvement actions

  • Template: "Based on our discussion, you'll [specific action] by [specific timeframe]."

• Support Commitment: Specific assistance you'll provide

  • Template: "To support you, I'll [specific resource/action/follow-up]."

Review Phase (Establish Follow-Up)

• Next Check-In: Specific time/date for follow-up

  • Example: "Let's check progress next Tuesday during your shift."

• Success Metrics: How improvement will be measured

  • Example: "We'll know this is working when we see [specific outcome]."

• Documentation Plan: How the conversation will be recorded

  • Example: "I'll note our discussion in the feedback log and send you a quick summary."

• Positive Reinforcement: End on an encouraging note

  • Example: "I'm confident you'll make good progress with this."

FOLLOW-UP SYSTEM

Progress Tracking

• Date of Initial Feedback: _________________

• Key Action Items:

• Employee Commitments: _________________

• Manager Commitments: _________________

• Follow-up Date 1: _______ Outcome: _______

• Follow-up Date 2: _______ Outcome: _______

• Resolution Date: _______ Result: _______

Reflection Questions (Complete after resolution)

• What went well in this feedback process?

• What could I improve in future feedback conversations?

• Were there any unexpected outcomes or insights?

• Is there a system/process issue that needs addressing?

• Should this feedback be shared more broadly (in anonymized form)?

SPECIAL SITUATION GUIDELINES

For Performance Issues

• Document specific examples with dates and metrics

• Connect to broader business impact

• Develop detailed improvement plan with clear milestones

• Follow company documentation requirements

• Consider involving HR for serious performance concerns

For Sensitive Personal Matters

• Ensure complete privacy

• Begin with positive acknowledgment

• Use a bridge phrase: "I need to discuss something personal that's difficult to talk about"

• Focus on workplace impact rather than personal judgment

• Offer appropriate support resources

• End with reassurance of value

For Cross-Cultural Considerations

• Research cultural norms if possible

• Be explicit about intentions

• Focus on concrete behaviors and outcomes

• Adjust directness as appropriate

• Ask about preferred feedback style

• Watch for non-verbal cues of discomfort

---

Quick Reference: The CLEAR Feedback Model

• C – Context: Set the stage appropriately

• L – Listen: Start with questions to understand perspective

• E – Evidence: Provide specific, observable examples

• A – Action: Develop collaborative improvement steps

• R – Review: Establish clear follow-up mechanisms

---

Downloadable from www.LeadershipLessons.co