Handling Defensive Reactions to Feedback
Defensive reactions often mask deeper insecurities. Approach with empathy, not frustration, to turn tension into trust.
This is Leadership Lessons, your blueprint for practical leadership success with actionable advice on how to excel as a manager, like how to craft your career narrative.
Let’s be honest: giving feedback is an art, but handling someone’s defensive reaction to your well-intentioned advice? That’s a whole circus act—complete with juggling egos, walking tightropes, and taming lions. Defensive reactions are natural, but if left unchecked, they can derail even the most constructive conversations. The good news? With a bit of finesse, you can guide the conversation back to productive territory. Here’s how.
This is a follow up to my previous article on delivering difficult feedback.
Spot the Signs Without Taking the Bait
Defensiveness rarely comes with a neon sign saying, “I’m feeling attacked!” Instead, it hides behind behaviors like interrupting, shifting blame, or overly justifying mistakes. Recognizing these behaviors early is essential to steering the conversation toward resolution rather than escalation.
For example, imagine a team member interrupts you mid-feedback to defend their actions, saying, “But I only missed the deadline because no one reminded me!” Instead of snapping back with frustration, pause and acknowledge what’s happening. Their reaction is a reflection of feeling exposed or vulnerable—not a deliberate attempt to derail the discussion.
Don’t take it personally. A defensive reaction often reflects internal insecurities, not a personal vendetta against your feedback skills. So, breathe deeply and channel your inner Zen master. Staying calm helps you remain in control of the conversation and keeps things from spiraling out of hand.
By recognizing the signs and staying composed, you set the stage for a more productive dialogue where emotions don’t overshadow the message. This clarity paves the way for your next move: disarming their defenses.
Disarm the "Fight or Flight" Response
When people feel cornered, their brains go into survival mode—fight, flight, or freeze. Your mission is to signal that they’re not under attack but rather in a safe space to collaborate.
Start by softening the tone of your feedback. A statement like, “I’m bringing this up because I care about your success,” can go a long way in lowering their defenses. Pair this with open body language: uncrossed arms, a calm tone, and an inviting demeanor.
Humor can also work wonders. For instance, during a heated project review, I once lightened the mood by quipping, “If we keep brainstorming this many reasons for what went wrong, we might end up writing a self-help book!” The laughter diffused the tension, allowing us to refocus on solutions. However, humor must be used with care—it works best in contexts where you have a strong relationship. With someone you don’t know well or when emotions are raw, joking can backfire and exacerbate the issue.
Once you’ve softened the initial resistance, the next step is crucial: validating their feelings without compromising your message.
Validate Their Feelings Without Agreeing
Validation doesn’t mean conceding your point; it’s about showing empathy for their perspective. Defensive people often feel unheard, so acknowledging their emotions can help de-escalate tension.
For instance, if they say, “I feel like you’re singling me out,” respond with, “I can see how it might feel that way, but that’s not my intention. Let’s work through this together.” This simple acknowledgment demonstrates respect for their experience without diluting your feedback.
Validation creates a bridge of trust, paving the way for more open communication. Be careful, though, not to validate to the point where your original message gets lost. Once trust is established, you can reframe the feedback as a shared goal.
Reframe the Feedback as a Shared Goal
I once had a department manager working for me who was struggling to connect with his team. Fresh out of college and in his first leadership role, he lacked the rapport-building skills needed for the job. I paired him with another manager who excelled at delivering tough feedback with a positive spin. One of the things she shared with him was the importance of framing feedback in a positive way. She told him":
"The conversation should not be you against them in a battle of wills and egos. It should be you and them together versus the problem."
That framing stuck with me; I had never heard it phrased quite like that. It’s a perspective I’ve shared countless times since.
Instead of saying, “You’re not meeting deadlines,” you might say, “I want to make sure we’re meeting deadlines more consistently. Let’s figure out how to get there.” This subtle shift in language fosters collaboration rather than confrontation.
Emphasize the benefits of addressing the issue, such as improved team performance or personal growth. With a shared objective in mind, it’s easier to engage in problem-solving—starting with asking clarifying questions.
You might also be interested in my article on giving positive recognition.
Ask Clarifying Questions
Defensiveness often arises from misunderstandings. Asking thoughtful, clarifying questions can cut through confusion and guide the conversation back on track.
For example, you could ask, “What do you think is the biggest challenge here?” or “How do you see this situation?” These questions invite the other person to share their perspective, making them feel heard and respected.
Follow up with, “What’s one thing we could tweak to make this easier for you?” This not only refocuses the discussion on solutions but also signals your willingness to collaborate.
By turning the spotlight onto problem-solving, questions help move the conversation beyond excuses and into actionable territory. However, if emotions still run high, a strategic pause might be necessary.
Take a Timeout if Needed
Despite your best efforts, some conversations reach an emotional boiling point. When this happens, a well-timed pause can be the reset button you both need.
Say something like, “I can see this is a lot to process right now. Let’s take a break and revisit it tomorrow.” This gives both parties time to reflect and cool off, ensuring the discussion resumes in a more productive headspace.
Taking a timeout isn’t a sign of failure; it’s a strategic move. By stepping away, you preserve the relationship and set the stage for a clearer, calmer conversation later on. When you return, be sure to end on a positive note.
Want to learn more about delivering clear, effective feedback? Check out this article.
End on a Positive Note
Defensive people often feel like their entire worth is being questioned. Counteract this by highlighting their strengths and contributions to the team. For example, you could say, “I really appreciate the creativity you bring to our projects. Addressing this issue will only help you shine even brighter.” Positive reinforcement leaves them feeling valued and motivated to improve.
Feedback is rarely a one-and-done deal. Following up shows that you’re invested in their success and reinforces the collaborative tone you’ve set. A quick message like, “Thanks for being open to our discussion. Let me know how I can support you,” keeps the lines of communication open. It also reminds them that feedback is part of an ongoing process, not a final verdict.
By combining encouragement with thoughtful follow-ups, you not only inspire growth but also strengthen the foundation of trust for future conversations.
Final Thoughts
Defensiveness is an inevitable part of giving feedback, but it doesn’t have to derail your efforts. By staying calm, empathetic, and focused, you can turn a defensive reaction into an opportunity for growth—for both of you. Just remember: feedback is a conversation, not a monologue. So, take it slow, stay curious, and don’t forget to pack a sense of humor.
Practical Tips for Managing Defensive Reactions
Moving from understanding to action is where real growth happens. Effective feedback isn’t just about knowing what to do—it’s about putting those principles into practice in ways that foster trust and collaboration. Here are some actionable steps to navigate defensive reactions with confidence, turning challenges into opportunities for connection and improvement.
Recognize Defensive Cues Early: Look for signs like interrupting, blame-shifting, or over-explaining, and stay calm when they arise.
Don’t Take it Personally: Understand that defensive reactions reflect internal struggles, not attacks on you.
Soften Your Tone: Start with empathetic statements like, “I care about your success,” to create a collaborative environment.
Use Humor Sparingly: Break tension with light, non-sarcastic humor to put the other person at ease.
Validate Feelings: Show empathy with phrases like, “I can see how you might feel that way,” without conceding your message.
Reframe Feedback as Shared Goals: Focus on “us versus the problem” to encourage collaboration.
Ask Thoughtful Questions: Use open-ended questions to clarify misunderstandings and guide the conversation toward solutions.
Pause When Necessary: If emotions run high, suggest taking a break and resuming the discussion later.
End with Positivity: Reinforce their strengths to leave the conversation on an encouraging note.
Follow Up: Check in with the person after the feedback session to show ongoing support.
Keep it Objective: Focus on specific behaviors or outcomes rather than personal attributes to avoid triggering defensiveness.
Practice Active Listening: Show genuine interest in their perspective by paraphrasing and summarizing their responses.
Mastering these skills takes patience and persistence. But each conversation handled with care strengthens your ability to deliver feedback that inspires rather than alienates. By integrating these strategies into your approach, you’ll not only manage defensiveness effectively but also build relationships founded on mutual respect and shared goals.
Follow me on LinkedIn